Transcript
Introduction to Reclosers and the ITIC Curve
Hello, everyone, and welcome to today’s white paper webinar. Today, we’re gonna talk about reclosers and the ITIC curve, and how this is really a problem for utilities and the equipment manufacturer in general because we have, at root, an incompatibility.
Background: The CBEMA Curve
To give you a little background, the ITIC curve or ITIC curves developed from the CBEMA curve, and the CBEMA curve was developed back in the 1970s. CBEMA is the computer business and equipment manufacturing. This was a group of computer server power supply folks that developed standards for how rugged these power supplies needed to be and how much ride-through they needed.
The original curve you see here in figure one, and this is a little bit blurry image, but from the standard, it divided volt disturbances into two metrics: how long did the disturbance last, and what did the voltage go to? So no matter what the disturbance was, whether it was a sag or a swell or a transient, it was boiled down to two numbers, a duration and a magnitude of retained voltage. And depending on what type of event it was, the graph gave manufacturers guidelines for how that equipment could react to it.
They created this CBEMA curve, and on the x-axis is time, the duration of the disturbance. We go from very small disturbances in the microsecond range, all the way to steady state, and then the retained voltage is in terms of percent nominal. The concept was, if it was a voltage sag, you’re gonna be under one hundred percent, so the retained voltage is lower than the nominal. And if it’s over that, that’s a voltage swell.
The ITIC Curve Replaces CBEMA
This curve was replaced back in the ’80s with the ITIC curve. The group renamed itself, and one of the problems with the original standard was it wasn’t well specified. These curves didn’t have formulas behind them. It wasn’t really clear where these break points actually were. Even though it’s often called the CBEMA curve, generally when people say that, they’re referring to the ITIC curve.
The actual curves were replaced by discrete break points with straight lines. Here, we’re dividing up the timescale from the microsecond range of a disturbance into fractions of a cycle, this is .01 cycles, for example, into the millisecond range, and then in tens of cycles into hundreds of cycles, and then ten seconds. Anything beyond ten seconds is considered steady state per the CBEMA graph. Now long-term at steady state, we have tolerances of plus or minus ten percent.
Three Categories of Voltage Events
If a disturbance is encountered, it can be plotted on this curve as a single dot, and the X coordinate is how long the disturbance lasted. The Y coordinate is what the voltage went to, whether it was high or low. So you might have a voltage sag, for example, in this region. If it lasted one millisecond and went to, say, seventy percent retained voltage, it would be right here.
The voltage event can really fall into one of three categories. If the voltage event is within the curve, then that’s the no interruption and function region. The equipment should be able to survive that and keep running correctly without any problem. At steady state, that’s plus or minus ten percent voltage, and as we get into the shorter timescales, the voltage tolerance is wider.
In fact, at twenty milliseconds and faster, we can have a sag that goes all the way to zero volts. We can actually have an interruption, and that equipment should have enough ride-through capability to survive through that if it’s less than twenty milliseconds. Also, in terms of overvoltage, we can have a voltage transient that actually hits up to five times the peak voltage if it lasts for less than a hundredth of a cycle. As the duration gets longer and longer, the allowable tolerance gets smaller and smaller.
If it’s a voltage sag that’s outside the curve in this region, this should not damage the equipment, but it won’t necessarily function correctly. If it’s an electronic power supply powering a computer, the computer may reboot, something may restart, or it may just shut down, but it shouldn’t damage anything. And then if it’s a voltage swell or an increase in voltage in this region, that might actually damage equipment. Not only will the equipment likely not function, but it could become damaged.
So this gives guidelines for equipment manufacturers, both in how much ride-through capability they need to add, how much bulk capacitance in the DC power supply, and how much it should be able to ride through a sag or interruption. And also how much surge suppression and how much energy it needs to be able to absorb in an overvoltage.
Reclosers and the Incompatibility with ITIC
Unfortunately, this standard wasn’t really designed in conjunction with electric utilities. This is an equipment manufacturing spec for equipment designers. It’s not a utility spec. As we see here in the paper, it’s actually almost impossible for utilities to strictly meet the standard because of the way reclosers operate.
With a recloser, what happens is when you have a fault on the line, the recloser will open and then try to reclose. It’ll try to clear that fault. If it’s, for example, a tree branch falling across the power line, that’s a momentary fault, and the recloser will open up before a fuse blows. Then if when it recloses, if the fault is gone, for example, a tree branch has fallen to the ground, then the recloser successfully completes the circuit, and the event is over.
It may take a few recloses to burn through a fault, but these reclosers are preventing much longer outages. If the recloser wasn’t there, you’d have likely a fault current flowing to where a fuse would blow or a breaker at a substation would be forced to operate. So these reclosers help sectionalize and isolate problems to the smallest number of customers and also prevent more frequent outages. Things that might be an outage for a customer that might last hours until a truck is rolled are now just a few cycles or maybe a half second of a deep sag while it tries to reclose a few times.
But unfortunately, the timing for these reclosers tends to create violations of the CBEMA graph.
Single-Phase Reclosers and Voltage Swells
What’s worse is the fact that reclosers often produce a voltage swell. What’s becoming more and more common are single-phase reclosers. With a recloser on a single-phase basis, if that faulted phase has fault current flowing through it, that’s gonna produce a deep voltage sag on that faulted phase. For example here, phase A is the faulted phase, and so customers on that phase, single-phase customers on that lateral, will see a deep sag or even an interruption.
But the other two phases will see an increase in voltage because the ground point has been shifted away towards the faulted phase. And so these vectors actually get longer. So if you have single-phase reclosers, that will produce voltage swells on the other phases while that fault current is flowing. The overvoltage depends on the grounding strategy on that circuit, and there’s an IEEE table for the overvoltage factor based on the type of grounding. Most common is a 20 or 30% voltage swell while that fault current is flowing.
What This Looks Like in a PQ File
What this looks like in a PQ file would be something like this, where we see a RMS voltage and current strip chart, and things are looking normal everywhere in the recording. We see some voltage sags, but you see these two isolated voltage swells out of nowhere. One goes to 140 volts, one to about 130 volts.
If you look at the waveforms, it’s clear that these are RMS events. See the step increase in voltage? One was three cycles long. One here, we’re looking at it on a continuous RMS graph instead of a sine wave graph. One was exactly 30 cycles long, the beginning and the end of this reclose. This corresponds to the timing set up in this recloser. So this customer saw two voltage swells: one that lasted three cycles, one that lasted a half a second. And both of these are gonna produce violations of the CBEMA graph.
CBEMA Curve Violations from Reclosers
As you’ll see in the paper and here in the slide, you’ll have events that are just outside the CBEMA curve. There are lots of events here when you have reclosers operating on that phase, and you’ll have events also in this portion when you have reclosers on other phases, if they’re single-phase reclosers. So any time that your reclosers operate, you’re effectively gonna have violations of the CBEMA graph inherent in how these work.
This is only a 20-millisecond breakpoint, so if it’s less than 20 milliseconds, you can have a sag all the way to zero. But many recloser operations are gonna last more than 20 milliseconds. That’s less than two cycles. If you’re at, say, three cycles, you’re gonna be right about here, and you’re only allowed to have a sag to 70% retained voltage. Many faults that reclosers are trying to clear are going to be at that level. In fact, just a fault without a recloser would also be a lower retained voltage but just lasts much, much longer. And so instead of dots here, you’re gonna have dots way out here.
You’re also gonna see voltage swells. On the top half of this graph, the 20% breakpoint is at three milliseconds. So if you have a 20% voltage swell, it can only last three milliseconds. That’s not even a half cycle. So that’s not long enough for our reclosers to try to clear faults on the other phases. And so you’re gonna have plenty of events up in this region also.
So there’s a built-in incompatibility between the minimum standard equipment manufacturers go by and the way utilities need to operate to minimize interruptions and improve reliability. There’s this trade-off between reliability and voltage quality in terms of CBEMA violations.
SEMI F47 Standard
Since this isn’t a utility spec, many utilities don’t record ITIC events, but this is the most likely graph that a utility customer will present to the utility if they’re doing their own power quality investigation because it’s much more common on the industrial side.
A related graph is the SEMI F47 standard, which is very similar to the ITIC curve but with slightly different breakpoints, but the same concept of a minimum allowed event based on three different areas: the normal operation area; the area where no equipment damage will happen but the equipment may misoperate, you may have a contactor drop out or something reset; and then this prohibited region where this may actually cause equipment damage.
Again, utilities aren’t likely to violate the top half of this unless we have voltage swells from those reclosers. If you don’t have single-phase reclosers, you’re a lot less likely to have events in this area. But those single-phase reclosers can be helpful in further sectionalizing parts of the grid to improve reliability for customers. On the other hand, utilities very often have events in this section because this is right where reclosers fall, single phase or three phase.
Conclusion
That really concludes the topic here in the white paper. The basic message is there’s an inherent incompatibility between the CBEMA or ITIC standard and how US utilities are structured and how reclosers help improve reliability for customers at perhaps the cost of violating this curve.
Unfortunately, if this curve were just a little bit structured differently, if this breakpoint were a little bit here, giving a little more time for these sags, and this was a little bit higher, there would be a lot more compatibility, because equipment would be designed with a little bit more ride-through and a little bit more ruggedness. Now, of course, equipment manufacturers don’t have to design to the minimum of the standard, and some equipment is better designed with actual operation in mind, not just the minimums. But that’s not always the case.
If you have any questions about the white paper, give us a call anytime at 1-800-296-4120 or send an email to support@powermonitors.com. And thanks for attending. Have a great day.